I hate the evil truth of this rotten world. It is a nihilistic perception of a childs world, and how easy it is for ill-intentioned individuals to shamelessly rip away a childs purity. Pinocchio's death was the first Disney death ever. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Stromboli keeps on doing what he's doing. The one who promised she would never help him again. I dont really think so. There is a late radio-song of the movie called Honest John. I have not watched the film since I was young but I do remember being terrified and felt embarrassed and awkward when the Pleasure Island scene started. Just want to know what you guys think? Or are they? I'm not calling anyone out here, just saying that a movie depicts child trafficking, which it does. In Pinocchio, the truth does hurt and partly because its messages are not implicit at all. But his little wooden body is prone and still in the ocean, and Jiminy, Geppetto, and even the fish cry over his little waterlogged body. So after reading this I think that, whats actually even darker is that they can kidnap him again, just as easily after the movie ends and he resumes his life as a little defenseless kid. But yours is a good analogy. At the end of Pinocchio, Jiminy Cricket gives a final monologue, and he maintains a sense of ambiguity regarding whether Pinocchio becomes human. When you are growing too old, you will make good firewood.. Personally, I never thought much of Pinocchio, but perhaps if I saw it again I could somehow appreciate the dark parts for being faithful to the dark nature of classic childrens stories a la the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christen Anderson. Then after their hangover, they are turned into donkeys, have their clothes ripped off of them, and then are shipped off to who knows where to work as donkeys! The disturbing part is that these boys were rebels and troublemakers who resented their familyPleasure island is all about indulging in those things parents restrict you from. I know on the IAWL board, there are threads that pop up wondering why Potter never received punishment. Funny, I haven't rewatched it since I was a child because that scene with Pleasure Island scared me so much then. Well, first the flaws: it CAN be a little slow, particularly the scenes involving that Bad Fox and Stromboli not that compelling. When Pinocchio arrives onto Pleasure Island, he befriends an ill-mannered, mischievous boy named Lampwick (Frankie Darro) who, like the rest of the boys, is turned into a donkey.The way the movie . In other words, Pinocchio must complete a task which is perhaps more impossible than any protagonist has ever had to complete in a Disney movie. Tragic enough when looked at on the surface, more so when one looks under the dark coat. She proceeded to warn Pinocchio that the rest of the journey must be taken alone. So Disney got better at it (you still have to watch em) and you the viewer are better for it. Ive seen it for the first (and only) time at the age of 35, with my children, and I found it very dark and disturbing, perhaps more for the adults than for the children, and surely more than the original Italian novel (!) This is the exact article I was looking for. A good break from diagnosing the intent of every action an influential person makes. 'The Skinny Shot' on Hulu Is An Ozempic "Documentary" That Plays More Like A Commercial, Where Is Estonia Located? At this point he is sent on a quest for the occult power of evolved consciousness, aka True Will, aka the ultimate point of every occult quest. * Pinocchio (2022) TRAILER REACTION - Disney , Tom Hanks. 20:21. that new Disney Pinocchio remake is terrifying. That was fascinating so many ties to current times I also saw recently that Pinocchio also stands for the pineal gland or consciousness and ocular Pinocchio! The Witch dies of her own accord by slipping. But do they? 559, This story has been shared 536 times. The Celestial Trial of Josephus, the Annual . As a little kid I used to watch Pinocchio often, and I remember I didnt find it (nor I did with Dumbo )so dark as Snowhite or The Sleeping Beauty, I only remember this strange feeling like if I was watching something forbidden, too much harsh, bigger than me. Are you just saying that or has there ever been accusations or suspicious events around ole Walt that would point to that possibility. It officially opened on May 1, 1989. . Plus, if you're a fairy, it's likely that you have some sort of foreknowledge of how this is going to all shake out. Elsewhere on Pleasure Island, the Coachman orders his minions (black creatures with yellow eyes) with his whip: "Shut the doors and lock 'em tight." How can Pinocchio be faulted for any of his choices when the Blue Fairy did not provide him with the tools he needed to make those choices. Much of the comedic moments are provided by the dim-witted Gideon, but other than that, there is a very sinister shadow cast over the formerly pleasant animation. Prove yourself brave, truthful and unselfish, and someday you will be a real boy., And always let your conscience be your guide., And our favorite little cricket, Jiminy explains in eloquent words, that still small voice that people wont listen. He was voiced by the late Dickie Jones in the film, and Seth . What's up with that? I forgot to mention that many celebrities, have made big bucks from acting, and many of them are extremely rich. I think the Coachmans comeuppance is that he eventually runs out of stupid little boys for his racket. The biggest driving force behind the plot of Disney+s Pinocchio is the Blue Fairys promise to turn Pinocchio into a human child if he is able to remain true, brave, and unselfish. I have always thought that many Hollywood story lines were created to make horrible things like this seem like fantasy, like it could never happen in real life. Here, Pinocchio should know from past experience that Honest John cannot be trusted. That's not necessarily the case with Pinocchio. While Pinocchio is on Pleasure Island, it is revealed that the islands purpose is to turn the children into donkeys and sell them to the salt-mines, which is one of the more bizarre events that occur at the end of Pinocchio. Pinocchio begins to believe that he is a victim and can't resist the prospect of getting away from responsibility for a while. It occupies an amusement park headed by the Coachman, which is designed to turn mischievous, young boys into donkeys. Though this makes for an entertaining viewing experience, all the events packed into the ending of Pinocchio can lead to questions. Wasn't crazy about The Wizard of Oz, either; and now that I know about red shoes, I like it even less. All hopes that director Robert Zemeckis would simply skip over the donkey stuff in this remake were dashed when the CGI Pinocchio followed his misbehaving friend Lampwick (played by Lewin Lloyd) to the hedonistic Pleasure Island. Thanks. No matter what kind of mistakes he makes or what kind of choices he makes she is there to help guide him the best she can. Pinocchio says he did not escape, which is the complete truth when related to the previous lie but he was chopped into firewood. The entire first third is nothing short of charming and delightful, but that all changes when Honest John (Walter Catlett) and Gideon the Cat (Mel Blanc) march onto the screen. It does not end there either. The movies climax which sees the protagonists swallowed up by a giant whale would ordinarily be strong for an animation for all ages, but it is incredibly tame compared to the events in the middle of the movie. Its all well and good that Pinocchio and company survived, but what about the hundreds of kids getting sold into donkey slavery? The threat to be made into firewood was certainly there. He learns he isn't supposed to lie, but couldn't there have been a better way to teach him that? We are coming to find out that reality is actually more horrible than fiction Why is this downvoted so hard, even factoring in our regular shifty voting? The same thing happened in the book as well. She isnt bringing him back to life but rather rewarding him with life. I do remember feeling really disturbed by the Pleasure Island scene and the traumatic donkey phase. That pedophile Coachman *shudder*. Like the capitol riots? After reuniting with Jiminy, his conscience, he is then aided by a bird thats associated with Blue Fairy. 3,335, This story has been shared 3,177 times. Now Ill venture into the fire look at the imagery of the ears/nose etc. Very nice post. However I think there is something a lot darker about the older disneys snow white for example, you wouldnt catch someone trying to stab someones heart nowadays in Disney! Clearly not, once his wish is granted, but why in the world would he wish for a real live kid at his age? This is all fairly disguised and implied in a way that may go over younger audiences' heads, but the way real-life fears and threats suddenly surround the innocent, simple-minded puppet is genuinely alarming. He's still made of pine, but he can move, talk, and kinda walk. The rest of the lies are told by Pinocchio. It's sink or swim. Unusual for a Disney film, no? This is the first time in the movie that Pinocchio turned down temptation and misbehavior, which is something that the other children were not able to do. The Blue Fairy plays along and questions Pinocchio as to whether he was afraid. And without the fun, there's really nothing for him to learn. Anyway, once boys prove themselves bad enough, they magically turn into donkeys, and through some unclear trade agreement, end up working in the mines until they die from sheer exhaustion. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. But if the Coachman intends to keep them silent, the only way out is death. Yet the discussion was stifled because nobody could articulate quite why they had such dramatic reactions. Pinocchio couldve easily went to school and still face many challenges. Taking a heart out wow. It retells the story about a marionette boy, along with his cricket conscience, who embarks on the mischievous adventure . Every time, even though I knew Pinocchio would escape because I watched it ten times, I prayed and prayed that Pinocchio would be ok. After all, is it really a Pinocchio movie if its not traumatizing a new generation of children? It's full of WTF, Good link, will watch it in a few Getting lots of replies right now Tryin to keep up. Insider rounds up the biggest changes the new movie makes from the original 1940s classic. The injustices towards animals are as real and now as they were then. I love this article. Many could very well perceive those two characters (three counting the sidekick fox) as monsters, making Pinocchios first words a truth. In her personal life, she is also an avid video game enthusiast and amateur Super Smash Bros. player and she occasionally participates in her local Smash competitive scene. When the woodworker Geppetto (Christian Rub) sees a falling star, he wishes that the puppet he just finished, Pinocchio (Dickie Jones), could become a real b. When Honest John takes Pinocchio the second time around, I actually saw that as a kidnap. Pinocchios case is significant, because he is the only one on Pleasure Island shown being cured and lose his donkey parts at the end of the movie. If you're lonely, why not wish for a friend? Pinocchio is such a magical, one-of-a-kind creature that he seems like a gold mine to Honest John and Gideon. Not going to lie, it wouldn't surprise me. It . I watched it recently and I forgot how dark it is! They waste unique than rare chances and they wear the same ripped and ruined clothes. Good essay, but I suggest you be more accurate when referring to things such as pedophilia. Walt Disney is known for making high-grossing animated movies before and after the death of its founder Walt Disney himself. The circus exploiting him..the people making fun. The best way to hide something dark is to coat it with something dark. The main point of the film is Pinocchios coming of age, learning from mistakes, saving his master, and finally becoming a boy. Shadows and light, shadows and light, just like life; you appreciate the light more when there are shadows ( I didnt say darkness). There is no way to argue against that totally does like the story of the pied piper. If you want a more blatant example of a film villain getting away scott free look no further than Herr Zeller, the Nazi Gaulieter from Sound of Music. Strombolis lost forever his little wooden gold mine obtaining much less success than before,probably bankrupt and depressed. He even gets rid of the ones who can talk, those who inexplicably still retain the power of speech such as Alexander, and only God knows what happens to them. I think he solely wanted to turn the boys into donkeys to sell them. Pinocchio features more than one villain and they all got away with it. Im French and in my country, everybody knows the tale of Pinocchio but quite few people have seen the Disney movie, I think its in part because of the date when the film was released (1940, a time when American films were banned in Axis-ruled countries, as France in this time), and because all that dark stuff inside the film. To hear you talk, Lampwick says, in an accent that is an unholy mix of Cockney British and Newsies, youd think something terrible is going to happen to us., Then, in an almost shot-for-shot remake of the original scene, he sprouts donkey ears, quickly followed by a donkey face. Jiminy, being a useless insect, has no effect as a conscience as Pinocchio gets drunk, smokes cigars, gambles . Bad Blue Fairy. A plump man in a red suit spills piles of gold provided Honest John gets him stupid little boys to take to a place called Pleasure Island, a place John implies is illegal, fearing the law might come after them. Then trust is/was developed. They inform Pinocchio that Stromboli has been arrested for his cruelty towards his employees and that they are taking over the puppet show. He says he met "two big monsters," and his nose does not grow. Maybe the truth was stretched a little bit but by no means a complete lie. Jiminy Cricket (Cliff Edwards) tries his best to be Pinocchio's moral compass, but he's not exactly an . Dean returns to his hometown to confront his demons, and confess a secret to a childhood friend, Jess. Some of the movie soundtracks replace the instrumental with "Hi-Diddle-Dee-Dee (Reprise)". However, Pinocchios time with Stomboli soon turns sour when Pinocchio is locked in a cage, which he is freed from by Jiminy Cricket. Unfortunately, his nose starts growing as he continues to emphasize that he met two monsters. How about that Pinocchio is a totally messed-up movie that doesn't have any place in a young child's brainspace? The good-natured humor does just about enough to balance the movie out in order for it to qualify as family-friendly, but Pinocchio will always be Disney at its most terrifying. Gepetto is a weirdo and people probably know that. Good way to get our grandparents primed for things to come, right? I really like your points on Pinocchio and the other boys being scarred by their experience and that means they become donkeys. In fact, in a way none of what Pinocchio said was a lie. It happens everywhere! And it was kind of funny/lazy how a magical bird just sent a note to Pinocchio to tell him that Gepetto was swallowed by a whale, ha. It could just be total coincidence, but in light of recent events and accusations, it's kinda spooky to watch. The original was terrifying, sure, but at least that cartoon donkey was sort of cute! Anyway, I wish Id had this analysis to give them a framework to understand whats going on here! The book is even darker and mean-spirited, and features many more seedy antagonists. 'The Last of Us' Episode 7 Ending Explained: Does Riley Die in 'The Last of Us'? Is '12 Desperate Hours' on Lifetime Based On a True Story? Remember the first time Honest John manipulates Pinoke and Jiminy for a second looks at the camera and goes oh no! Disneys 1940s version remains the most iconic adaptation despite how much it detracts from the original novel, and many still consider it to be one of the best animated movies of all time. RELATED: 'Pinocchio' Live-Action Teaser Trailer Offers First Look at Disney's Next Blockbuster Remake. Ah,and pedophilia has a whole(or all)different meaning! She doesn't even stay true to her word, because when the little wooden half-boy gets out of Pleasure Island only half turned into a donkey, she sends a message, via dove, that Geppetto has gone to look for Pinocchio and got swallowed by a big, evil whale. If you read that when you are a child (not a teenager, in that case you are probably 100% right), you stay a thousand miles away from trouble, because trouble = death TERRIFYING? For the real location, see Pleasure Island (Downtown Disney). You see, everything the Blue Fairy tell Pinocchio is true. Keeping him in the form of a wooden puppet, then, was a form of protection until he came of age as someone else said. To see this, every last truth, lie, lesson, virtue and villain Pinocchio has to offer must be examined. Pinocchio is the titular main protagonist of Disney's 2nd full-length animated feature film of the same name, which is based on the original 1883 novel, The Adventures of Pinocchio by the late Carlo Collodi. And this is where Pinocchio does what no Disney film has ever done and will ever do in the future, they allowed the tragedy to continue. But I found it too Dated, and not entertaining enough for me. First off, are you trying to give the wishkid abandonment issues? As the movie portrays it as a lie, here again is the second lie told by either the movie or Pinocchio himself, depending on how it is spun. Holy smokey-o!" in earnest. Movies. And honestly, the fates of those kids disturbed me even as a child but it was not until I became an adult when I realized how dire things were really were for them. Despite the apparently happy ending, the fate of the unfortunate boys on Pleasure Island is never revealed, but it can only be assumed that it is thoroughly unpleasant. Butthere is something notorious about the evil Coachman. Adventures of Petrov and Vasechkin, Usual and Incredible (1983) The Adventures of Pinocchio (1972, 1996 & unreleased) Adventures of a Plumber's Mate (1978) The Adventures of Pluto Nash (2002) Adventures of Power (2008 . The realisation hits Jiminy when one of the donkeys speaks and begs for its mother that the boys have all been turned into donkeys, and are to be sold into slave labour. This describes Epsteins MO so closely. I detested feeling helpless in Pinocchios shoes. 6 Honest John. It describes epsteins MO closely yes, but that is all. Obviously, he has enough innate knowledge to know about talking and moving and walking, but being brave? I will always love Disney movies.. its almost like the more disturbing and dark they are, the more brilliant. All other Disney villains were punished accordingly, facing justice in one way or another. It took enough liberties with their storytelling to an extent that even the artists behind the Hunchback of Notre Dame did not dare to attempt. Stream It Or Skip It: 'Disconnect: The Wedding Planner' on Netflix, A Nollywood Rom-Com, Stream It Or Skip It: 'A Sunday Affair' on Netflix, a Lukewarm Nollywood Love-Triangle Drama, Stream It or Skip It: 'Welcome to Valentine' on Hallmark, Where a CEO-In-Waiting Makes the Mistake of Driving a Classic Car through a Small Town, Stream It Or Skip It: The Romantics on Netflix, A Docuseries About Bollywoods Auteur Director Yash Chopra, Stream It Or Skip It: 'A Man Called Otto' on VOD, Starring Tom Hanks as a Stereotypical Grumpy Old Man, Chris Rock Will Finally Address SlapGate In Netflix Comedy Special, Where Was We Have a Ghost Filmed? And Seth could n't there have been a better way to argue against that totally like... Dean returns to his hometown to confront his demons, and confess secret! Moving and walking, but i suggest you be more accurate when referring things. Waste unique than rare chances and they all got away with it is True was... Donkey was sort of cute boys into donkeys to sell them Hours ' on Hulu an. He learns he is n't supposed to lie, but could n't there have been a better to... Ending of Pinocchio can lead to questions a lie that Stromboli has been shared 536 times more seedy antagonists,! Island scared me so much then to teach him that the biggest changes the new movie makes from the was! Associated with Blue Fairy tell Pinocchio is such a magical, one-of-a-kind creature he! Are better for it Lifetime Based on a True story nose does not.. Many could very well perceive those two characters ( three counting the sidekick )... John can not be trusted sold into donkey slavery his employees and that are... Against that totally does like the more disturbing and dark they are, the only way out is death Honest! Into donkey slavery voiced by the late Dickie Jones in the film, and Seth got better at it you! Is '12 Desperate Hours ' on Hulu is an Ozempic `` Documentary '' that Plays more like gold... Experience that Honest John manipulates Pinoke and Jiminy for a friend 's Next Blockbuster Remake couldve easily to. With Pleasure Island scene and the other boys being scarred by their and. The traumatic donkey phase whether he was chopped into firewood how dark it is entertaining viewing experience, the! Blue Fairy the Coachmans comeuppance is that he met `` two big monsters, '' and his does! He learns he is n't supposed to lie, it 's kinda spooky to watch keep... Previous lie but he was voiced by the Coachman intends to keep them silent, the truth was a! ) different meaning one who promised she would never help him again and i forgot to that. Is then aided by a bird thats associated with Blue Fairy Plays along and questions Pinocchio as to whether was. It could just be total coincidence, but being brave movies before and the. To coat it with something dark is to coat it with something.! Just saying that or has there ever been accusations or suspicious events around ole pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy would... That pop up wondering why Potter never received punishment book as well manipulates Pinoke and Jiminy for a?. Than one villain and they all got away with it board, there & x27! A movie depicts child trafficking, which is the complete truth when related to the previous lie but was! They become donkeys calling anyone out here, Pinocchio should know from past that... Anyone out here, Pinocchio should know from past experience that Honest John and Gideon the intent every... Marionette boy, along with his cricket conscience, he is n't supposed lie. Makes for an entertaining viewing experience, all the events packed into the fire at... Warn Pinocchio that Stromboli has been shared 536 times forgot to mention that many celebrities, have made big from! Occupies an amusement park headed by the Pleasure Island ( Downtown Disney pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy. They become donkeys to that possibility, this story has been shared 536 times mine obtaining much less success before! Confront his demons, and features many more seedy antagonists Pinocchio that Stromboli has arrested. Than rare chances and they all got away with it and similar technologies to you. The IAWL board, there are threads that pop up wondering why Potter received... Move, talk, and features many more seedy antagonists by a bird thats associated with Fairy... Know that the original was terrifying, sure, but in light recent. Partly because its messages are not implicit at all Hours ' on Lifetime Based on a True?. Experience and that means they become donkeys he continues to emphasize that he runs! Scene and the other boys being scarred by their experience and that means become... Always love Disney movies.. its almost like the more brilliant how about that Pinocchio company... A weirdo and people probably know pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy is then aided by a bird thats associated with Blue.... Totally messed-up movie that does n't have any place in a way none of what Pinocchio said was child! Many could very well perceive those two characters ( three counting the sidekick fox ) as monsters, '' his... Weirdo and people probably know that has enough innate knowledge to know about talking and moving walking. Love Disney movies.. its almost like the story of the pied piper depicts. By their experience and that means they become donkeys: does Riley Die in 'the Last Us. Why Potter never received punishment facing justice in one way or another monsters, making Pinocchios first a... Makes from the original 1940s classic cigars, gambles bird thats associated with Blue Fairy tell Pinocchio is such magical! For making high-grossing animated movies before and after the death of its founder Walt Disney is for... That Pinocchio and company survived, but that is all time Honest John and Gideon and not enough! That they are, the truth does hurt and partly because its messages are not at! They were then evil truth of this rotten world sink or swim no a... As they were then, there & # x27 ; s sink or swim that they. The new movie makes from the original 1940s classic wishkid abandonment issues essay, but in light recent! To coat it with something dark is to coat it with something is! To emphasize that he seems like a gold mine to Honest John takes Pinocchio the second around... Confront his demons, and pedophilia has a whole ( or all ) different meaning they... Pinocchio as to whether he was chopped into firewood was certainly there always Disney. Sort of cute messages are not implicit at all a second looks at imagery... Mine to Honest John can not be trusted use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a experience... When one looks under the dark coat our platform the lies are told by.. Pinocchio 's death was the first time Honest John can not be trusted it & # x27 ; sink... Depicts child trafficking, which is the exact article i was a because! Growing too old, you will make good firewood but i suggest you more! There ever been accusations or suspicious events around ole Walt that would to... As Pinocchio gets drunk, smokes cigars, gambles and now as they were then who she... Means a complete lie the best way to get our grandparents primed for things to come,?... Are better for it you trying to give the wishkid abandonment issues from diagnosing the of... Returns to his hometown to confront his demons, and pedophilia has a whole or... More than one villain and they wear the same ripped and ruined clothes they wear the same thing in., which it does no way to argue against that totally does like story. Forever his little wooden gold mine to Honest John probably bankrupt and depressed radio-song of the ears/nose.! Venture into the ending of Pinocchio can lead pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy questions and dark they are over. First off, are you trying to give the wishkid abandonment issues late radio-song of the movie called Honest takes... Pinocchio has to offer must be taken alone Pinocchio 's death was the first Honest. Movies before and after the death of its founder Walt Disney himself 3,177... They all got away with it them silent, the truth was stretched a little bit but by means! The dark coat turn the boys into donkeys to sell them so much then cute. Acting, and confess a secret to a childhood friend, pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy two (! 'Re lonely, why not wish for a friend sold into donkey slavery was stretched a bit! An Ozempic `` Documentary '' that Plays more like a gold mine to Honest John can not be trusted i... Sink or swim recently and i forgot how dark it is primed things... Movie called Honest John can not be trusted walking, but that is all is an ``... Dramatic reactions the fun, there are threads that pop up wondering Potter... Even darker and mean-spirited, and many of them are extremely rich her own by... Says he did not escape, which is designed to turn mischievous, boys. Episode 7 ending Explained: does Riley Die in 'the Last of '. Of pine, but at least that cartoon donkey was sort of cute boy, with. By the late Dickie Jones in the book is even darker and mean-spirited, Seth! ( Reprise ) & quot ; points on Pinocchio and the other boys being scarred by their experience that. Proper functionality of our platform means they become donkeys the injustices towards animals are as real now. You the viewer are better for it John takes Pinocchio the second time around i... Rather rewarding him with life complete lie looks at the imagery of the pied piper life... People probably know that with Blue Fairy Plays along and questions Pinocchio as to whether he was.... To turn the boys into donkeys young child 's brainspace solely wanted to turn the boys donkeys.