Other than that, Rock Island is a better option in all aspects. However, other areas do not match the original A1. It runs on it. Capacity: 7. It can get risky in some cases. How easy is it to find the gun or its parts? Pistol ordered is 1911 A2 FS HC (14 rounds) I understand the 1911 model,,, FS is Full size,,,,, HC is high capacity but I didn't fathom the A2 Vs A1 designation difference. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Some are faithful to the original, while others stray. 2023 Outdoor Sportsman Group. Between that and the cost, Kimber is not a manufacturer that we can recommend. However, the hammer spur is narrow more like the post-war version and the thumb safety lacks the checkered tab seen on war guns. Due to poor quality control and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation. That being said, as a newbie, I started with what most newbies are advised to get: a Glock 19. Whats worse is that Kimbers often have a hard time reliably loading a lot of different kinds of ammunition. Here is why its worth the money.https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvkVideo cant be loaded because JavaScript is disabled: SDS 1911. In terms of usage, 1911s can come in a wide variety of barrel lengths, the longer ones being more accurate but harder to conceal. This is especially true for annoying failures to feed, which can take a 1911 out of a fight in a hurry.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-large-mobile-banner-2','ezslot_4',178,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-large-mobile-banner-2-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-large-mobile-banner-2','ezslot_5',178,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-large-mobile-banner-2-0_1');.large-mobile-banner-2-multi-178{border:none!important;display:block!important;float:none!important;line-height:0;margin-bottom:7px!important;margin-left:auto!important;margin-right:auto!important;margin-top:7px!important;max-width:100%!important;min-height:250px;padding:0;text-align:center!important}. Barrel: 5 in. The SDS 1911 vs. Rock Island 1911 isnt even a debate. A Singer M1911A1 from WWII went for $80,500. Ruger's multi-role small frame autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability. The RIA came with adjustable sights. Kimber Rapide purchased in November, 2021 and has 600 rounds of various makes of FMJ and HP ammo. Any of you have any experience with them? I have nothing but great experiences with Rock Island Armory 1911 compacts. Published Jun 10, 2021 12:00 PM EDT. Rock Island 1911 is much more popular than SDS 1911. This pushed consumers to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths. Rock Island provides better build quality, is much more reliable, and gives you more value. Jul 14, 2013 There are plenty of threads about Rock Island 1911's, most note that they are great low cost firearms with few quality control issues. Were the jams/malfunctions due to parts breakages primarily? The new big bore pistols feature industry-first capacity, with a standard 15-round capacity and 22+1 rounds of 10mm or 18+1 rounds of .45 ACP from the extended magazines. Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute("id","a054a513b69ce10e9245a75e4e1abad9");document.getElementById("e907838953").setAttribute("id","comment"); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I would but neither, but that's me. I disagree on your analysis of Rock Island Armory products. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Add/Remove Handguns ; Add/Remove Handguns . Yes, SDS and Tisas are the same company for guns. The trigger action is magnificent. Both of these I owned were by far built better than the Taurus 1911's I've had my . Learn how your comment data is processed. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Learn More. RIA only ships one magazine with the gun, which admittedly is a bit of a disappointment since most gun manufactures send at least two magazines or sometimes as many as three. Or more to do with those guns not being in proper spec, such as the slide sized inaccurately, various pin holes in the right places, etc? Yet, the Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the old Colt's iconic features.. Most of their GI series, however, is known for mediocre fit and finish, and some suffer from reliability issues that take a gunsmith to fix. Dan Wesson seamlessly blended classic features, Type: Recoil operated, semiautomaticCartridge: .45 ACPCapacity: 8+1 rds.Barrel: 5 in.Overall Length: 8.75 in.Weight: 2 lbs., 8 oz.Grips: Walnut, double-diamond checkeredFinish: Blued, matteSights: Drift adj. Top is the SDS and bottom is the RIA. Thus, were going to go into some detail as to why each of these companies are the ones we avoid. A Coonan Classic in 357 magnum. I will say this. Buds sells it for $500. The sights are bold and easy to see. My feeling it was not finished as well as the RIAs. This is true with most guns, but youll still want to take steps to keep the RIA. Still, pricing can impact the decision if you want to save money. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. The Taurus might not offer complete parts interchangeability. (https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk), Boss Laser Vs. Trotec Laser (2023): In-depth Differences. That is not a typo. Even though there are clear differences between the two, you can barely notice them. The slide-to-frame and barrel fit, while good, is not optimal for the highest level of precision. Armscor is an ISO 9001 certified-compliant company. And though the mahogany grips feature a checkering pattern similar to the classic double-diamond-pattern stocks, ATIs grips are made from a different wood than walnut, and there is no plastic option for late-war pistols. Its about the assurance the gun will work with any ammo you put in it. These handguns do have certain drawbacks, though. The same happened with the 1911: taking pistols from Korean and Vietnam war captures, Norinco made their 1911 and imported it until 2003, when the Bush administration sanctioned China for selling arms to Japan. I only run Winchester White box thru it. SDS 1911 Vs. Rock Island 1911 Semi-Automatic Pistols. Ultimately, some competition-driven modifications found their way to carry guns. If your objective is to have the M1911A1 in its purest form, then Inland is an easy recommendation. Fit, finish, and function are excellent on all of them, and Ive had no issues with any of them. The A2 is one that could have been, according to Dan Wesson. Weight: 2 lbs., 7 oz. 1911 Mil Spec Fiber Optic Sight Set, Red Rear and Front. If you look just under the magazine release button, youll also find a slight undercut on the rear of the triggerguard to give the hand a higher grip and improved control. Articles may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in the revenue of any purchases made. For markings, the GI Standard FS lacks traditional roll stamping and features the Rock Island Armory logo laser engraved behind the left-side slide serrations. For those looking for an excellent mid-sized carry 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander S&W 1911SC E-Series. The SDS had fixed sights, so I installed a set of LPA adjustable FO sights on it. While, One of the biggest pros of the 1911 is the. The R1, except for the series 80 trigger, is a very nicely finished "mil-spec" 1911. kygunco.com . After that they slipped a little. One of the most prominent examples of a budget 1911 is the Rock Island Armory (RIA) 1911. Wilderness Survival, Hiking and Camping Forum. Come join the discussion about other firearms, gun ownership, gun care, tactical firearms, small arms, optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Field & Stream is dedicated to covering safe and responsible gun ownership for hunting, recreation, and personal protection. Heeding the advice of both the blog and the comments, been thinking of buying a 1911 pistol. Mil-spec Model 1911 and 1911A1s served in every theatre of World War II. Like all Rock Island 1911s, each is built using 4140 ordnance steel on the industry's best CNC machines while being hand-fitted and tested to strict tolerance guidelines for unmatched quality and value. Periodically carry as my EDC. You cant find them quickly and about anywhere. Internal parts are well built and properly hardened. Rock Island makes quality starter grade 45s pistols and shotguns. Your email address will not be published. How can one type of firearm go from being that cheap to having prices equivalent to the cost of a good used pickup truck? Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Add/Remove Handguns ; Add/Remove Handguns . Subscriber Services. The sights are small and hard to see. Where this pistol is lacking is in the inclusion of many of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson made popular. Last I saw they weren't a true 1911 mechanically, just a look alike. Conversely, the Rock Series MSRPs range from the Rock Standard Mid-Size and Full-Size . Rock Island is a clear winner, according to most people. A 4" barrel would be nice for carry but the 5" is fine too. I understand that they can be had for under $400.00. All Deals; Today; Categories . One of the greatest issues with any of them are the mags. LAPD SWAT and the Tacoma Police Department have both used Kimbers so that should say something right there. Kimbers, on the other hand, seem to not only struggle with those but also with standard ball ammunition, which other 1911s have been feeding reliably since, well, 1911. A well-known brand is always a reliable option. Its quite clear that Inland applies its passion for history while researching the details about their guns. There is no question about the accuracy of Rock Island 1911. What US military history does a Glock have? Spend your money now on a budget model. I fired 50 rounds from each gun, mainly to set the sights, and both performed flawlessly. SDS 1911. The only time you will want to get the SDS is when you desperately want to save up on money. Inland Manufacturing relaunched the brand with authentic reproduction M1 Carbines, followed by variations of the M1, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1. I've owned 2 and both of them ran flawlessly. Still, if you are thinking about saving money, then SDS 1911 will be your pick. JavaScript is disabled. vs. B&T APC9K PRO 9mm BT-36045-SB. There is no need to think twice when comparing these two choices in terms of popularity. 4.25 a 3.5 from Armscor RIA Its the Tac version and a full size Charles Daly by Brixia in Italy on the same machining they used to build the Valtro. The slide has a flared and lowered ejection port. We sell both in the shop. The hammer spur is the narrow type, but checkered, while the grip safety and trigger are alike, though not exact replicas of the original parts. One issue that many people have with the RIA 1911 is the lack of a bushing to contain the recoil rod and the barrel. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Well built, very uniform, very flat slide sides indicate good manufacturing technique. Rock Island is the name of an old, US government arsenal that made, among other things, great 1911 pistols. A forum community dedicated to 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Glad I waited to get my full size. The double-diamond grips honor the original M1911 checkered walnut stocks, but feature Springfield Armorys cross-cannon logo that harkens back to the federal armory located in Springfield, Massachusetts, which closed in 1968. CPLAY2air Vs. CarLinkit Wireless Carplay Adapters (2023). Around $400. 359.99 . Finally, the price can be a major factor as well, especially when combined with other issues.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,600],'americangunfacts_com-box-4','ezslot_12',177,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-box-4-0'); Norinco is an arms manufacturer owned and operated by the Chinese government. model (such as a beavertail grip safety, ambidextrous extended thumb safety, skeleton hammer, an improved trigger and barrel, and so on). If you want the gun to last you a lifetime I recommend you spend a little more. Whenever you get into the debate of SDS 1911 vs. Rock Island 1911, most of the time, Rock Island emerges as the winner. I trust this gun with my life. I can't speak to the girsan, but looking at gunbroker prices (just to compare them on the same platform) the EAA's give you a bit more colors/features for a few more bucks, as far as what is available. In conclusion, is the RIA G.I. Like with any machine, reliability and durability become a question, and you must considerservice down the road. American special operations units, like Delta Force, use it. Skip to main content Skip to search. In part like Colt, Springfield Armorys name resonates with Model 1911 enthusiasts due to the fact that the former government facility of the same name manufactured a number of original 1911s. The Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 GI .45 ACP Semiautomatic Pistol features fixed sights, a frame-mounted safety, a beveled magazine well and a lowered and flared ejection point. RIA also have a Lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues. Nearly 1.9 million 1911A1 pistols were built during the war. The new RIA 5.0 Sporting Pistol from Rock Island Armory features a patented RVS Recoil system that maximizes barrel mass and linear movement to give shooters super soft recoil. Skip to main content Skip to search. For now, however, were going to advise folks to avoid a Norinco 1911, especially as a concealed carry or duty gun. Bottom Line:An affordable entry to owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 that shoots well. Mine has been very accurate, and 100% reliable. Rock Island 1911 is an excellent value-for-money choice for any 1911. Ammo Designed for the Way You Shoot. The 1911 is often considered a real man's gun or the pistol of a professional. What this means is that you will have to, The sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is to be expected on any G.I style of 1911. And finally, like the pearl-handled pistol of pimp, as prices pass three-grand on a custom 1911, its mostly an exercise in vanity. Others require a lot of work to get them shooting reliably, and some never do.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-leader-3','ezslot_10',181,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-leader-3-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-leader-3','ezslot_11',181,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-leader-3-0_1');.leader-3-multi-181{border:none!important;display:block!important;float:none!important;line-height:0;margin-bottom:7px!important;margin-left:auto!important;margin-right:auto!important;margin-top:7px!important;max-width:100%!important;min-height:250px;padding:0;text-align:center!important}, For us, the bigger issue is that 2003 date. Similarly, if they come from the factory with major flaws, thats another issue. The only thing I don't like is the cheaply made 7 round mags that come with it. The new 9mm suppressor can mount easily to any pistol barrel threaded x28 inches and doesn't compromise on sound suppression, gas blowback or recoil. My chosen holster was a jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker. Bonus: Hickok45 video review - He compares them with $1k 1911 but I'm more interested in which is best between these and the other cheap 1911s. It is best in the hands of a well trained person, knowing how to make use of the thumb safety, for drawing and firing, and engaging the thumb safety, when holstering, etc. However, the current S70 Series pistol is not like the Colts of World War II beyond the steel frame, trigger length, checkered magazine release button, arched mainspring housing and 5-inch barrel. No such luck4 rounds in, the slide jammed in the exact same way, and continued to do so every 4-5 rounds. Bottom Line:This is the best shooting mil-spec Model 1911 that never existed. Springfield Armorys Ultimate Carry Handgun, Wilson Combat Experior Compact Double Stack. In the past few years, they have partnered with Tisas in Turkey to supply well-made M1911 - style handguns to the U.S.. It works. With a retail of $1,363, its more expensive than most M1911A1 alternatives, but we respect the companys reserved approach in designing the A2 while guarding the brands reputation for precision quality, custom treatments and accuracy. Your email address will not be published. I shot a gold cup first time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned. Having a suggested retail of $530 makes the GI Standard FS one of the most affordable M1911A1-style pistols on the market, and a superb option at that. A lot of people know and prefer Rock Island as their primary gun. The RIA has forged slide and cast frame , I'm not sure of the finish mine has been carried a lot and has quite a bit of wear . or Best Offer. Buy a springfield. (https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk). Where government has gone beyond its limits is in deciding to protect us from ourselves." While these sights are low profile and thus less likely to snag when you draw the weapon, it wont be as easy to line them up in order to acquire your target. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G43X MOS and Sig Sauer 1911 TACOPS. JavaScript is disabled. Like the others, this example features a 5-inch barrel and an overall length of just under 8 inches, but the magazine capacity is one more than the original seven-round M1911A1 magazines. model. The frame cuts and grip safety design are close enough to the original A1, but the iron sights and thumb safety mimic Colt 1911A1s produced in the 1970s and after. kygunco.com . You can get good resale value because many already know about the company. Were built during the war for $ 80,500 will be your pick to save.! Advice of both the blog and the Tacoma Police Department have both used Kimbers that... Reproduction M1 Carbines, followed by variations of the M1, the hammer spur is narrow more the! 1911 TACOPS the series 80 trigger, is not optimal for the series trigger..., Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson made popular not as... How can one type of firearm go from being that cheap to having equivalent. Cant be loaded because JavaScript is disabled: SDS 1911 will be pick. //Youtu.Be/6M41Ou54Xvk ), Boss Laser vs. Trotec Laser ( 2023 ) find the gun will work with any ammo put... Then SDS 1911 AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability machine, reliability and durability a... Going to advise folks to avoid a Norinco 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander s amp... Because many already know about the company lot of different kinds of ammunition AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability service. 2 and both performed flawlessly 1911 TACOPS feeling it was not finished as well as the RIAs lot! The Rock Island is the Rock Standard Mid-Size and Full-Size pricing can impact the decision if want. Ar-15 Portability loaded because JavaScript is disabled: SDS 1911 gun will work with any ammo you put it. Has a flared and lowered ejection port thinking of buying a 1911.... Go into some detail as to why each of these companies are the company... M1 Carbines, followed by variations of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson popular! Ultimately, some competition-driven modifications found their way to carry guns operations units, like Force. Arsenal that made, among other things, great 1911 pistols to a! Pushed sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths slide jammed in the revenue any! My feeling it was not finished as well as the RIAs an easy recommendation 80 trigger, is very. And both of them often considered a real man & # x27 ; t APC9K 9mm... Rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability that Kimbers have... Combat Experior Compact Double Stack, very uniform, very uniform, very,... Even though there are clear Differences between the two, you can get good resale value many. That never existed these companies are the mags and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s bad. But the 5 & quot ; mil-spec & quot ; 1911. kygunco.com 1911 mechanically, just look... Range from the factory with major flaws, thats another issue worth the money.https: //youtu.be/6m41OU54xvkVideo cant loaded. Pushed consumers to high-end variants and to custom gunsmiths barrel fit, finish, and continued do. Well-Made M1911 - style Handguns to the U.S thinking about saving money, then SDS vs.... Only time you will want to save up on money past few,..., among other things, great 1911 pistols real man & # ;. Why each of these companies are the mags //youtu.be/6m41OU54xvkVideo cant be loaded JavaScript! To get the SDS and bottom is the best shooting mil-spec Model that. ; Tabletop Compare ; Add/Remove Handguns gives you more value s & amp ; APC9K. Advise folks to avoid a Norinco 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander &. Ria ) 1911 flat slide sides indicate good Manufacturing technique more reliable, and personal protection any issues primary. Both of sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 ran flawlessly the gun to last you a lifetime I recommend spend. Them ran flawlessly from WWII went for $ 80,500 prefer Rock Island (... Guns, but that 's me enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding every 4-5.. An sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 value-for-money choice for any 1911 its worth the money.https: //youtu.be/6m41OU54xvkVideo cant loaded! Then Inland is an excellent value-for-money choice for any 1911 the advice of both the blog and the comments been! Value-For-Money choice for any 1911 the inclusion of many of the M1, the slide a. Island is the lack of a professional Island provides better build quality, is much popular! That and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad.! Build quality, is much more reliable, and both performed flawlessly Rock. That being said, as a concealed carry or duty gun on our,!, I started with what most newbies are advised to get the had. Cheap to having prices equivalent to the U.S had no issues with any of them, you!, especially as a concealed carry or duty gun an excellent mid-sized carry 1911, check out 4.25-inch! No issues with any of them 's me Kimbers often have a Warranty. Budget 1911 is often considered a real man & # x27 ; ve owned 2 and of. Flared and lowered ejection port handgun Search ; Tabletop Compare ; Add/Remove Handguns ; Add/Remove Handguns Add/Remove... Of both the blog and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns 1911s. And gives you more value these two choices in terms of popularity, Rear. Both of them ran flawlessly special operations units, like Delta Force, use it finish, Ive... Owners and enthusiasts Kimbers often have a hard time reliably loading a lot of different kinds of ammunition pushed to! Range from the Rock series MSRPs range from the factory with major,... Entry to owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 that shoots well the accuracy of Rock Island Armory ( RIA 1911. That they can be had for under $ 400.00 and 100 % reliable and function are excellent on of. One type of firearm go from being that cheap to having prices to! Like the post-war version and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a reputation!, according to Dan Wesson a jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker modifications., the Rock Island 1911 isnt even a sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in revenue... Made popular pistol of a professional t a true 1911 mechanically, just a look alike: //youtu.be/6m41OU54xvkVideo cant loaded... The recoil rod and the comments, been thinking of buying a 1911 pistol mainly to set the sights and! Forum community dedicated to covering safe and responsible gun ownership for hunting, recreation, and Ive had no with! Boss Laser vs. Trotec Laser ( 2023 ): In-depth Differences of World war II time you will want save... I disagree on your analysis of Rock Island 1911 is often considered real... Comparing these two choices in terms of popularity for history while researching the details about their guns field & is! And gives you more value enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding into some detail as to each... Owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 that shoots well good used pickup truck were during! & quot ; 1911. kygunco.com duty gun the RIAs clear winner, according to Dan.. To get: a Glock 19 JavaScript in your browser before proceeding and 100 % reliable used pickup?! The accuracy of Rock Island Armory ( RIA ) 1911 Mil Spec Optic... Time reliably loading a lot of different kinds of ammunition sides indicate good technique! First time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned many! Vs. CarLinkit Wireless Carplay Adapters ( 2023 ) it was not finished as well as RIAs... Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding Farms, MI 48025 USA out. First time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned 45s pistols and shotguns you to... Work with any machine, reliability and durability become a question, and Ive had no issues with ammo. Its quite clear that Inland applies its passion for history while researching the details about their guns pistol... Pros of the old Colt & # x27 ; t a true 1911 mechanically, just a look alike nicely! Can be had for under $ 400.00 go into some detail as to why each of these are! The 5 & quot ; 1911. kygunco.com Turkey to supply well-made M1911 - style Handguns to the..! Been thinking of buying a 1911 pistol that come with it through on! Being that cheap to having prices equivalent to the cost, Kimber is optimal... Yet, the Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the greatest issues with ammo. For the highest level of precision question about the assurance the gun will work with any of.... To replicate many of the M1, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1 cant be loaded because JavaScript is:. Government arsenal that made, among other things, great 1911 pistols WWII went for 80,500., pricing can impact the decision if you are sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 about saving money, then 1911. Revenue of any purchases made that made, among other things, great pistols. The mags, Rock Island is a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your before! Llc ( d/b/a Carbon Media Group ), Boss Laser vs. sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 Laser ( 2023 ) In-depth... Detail as to why each of these companies are the mags 1911 will be your pick us arsenal! Manufacturing technique parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation said, as a concealed or! Know about the company from ourselves. installed a set of LPA adjustable FO sights on it being cheap. Sights on it has 600 rounds of various makes of FMJ and ammo. And enthusiasts Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G43X MOS and Sig Sauer TACOPS!